When doing a short sale the debtor may receive a form 1099-C for the amount of the lender's losses. This is considered loan forgiveness in the eyes of the IRS and the lender may issue a form 1099-C.

If the debtor has other assets such as savings and is not insolvent, the debtor may end up being responsible to pay ordinary taxes on the amount of the 1099-C.

If the debtor settles a debt with a creditor for less than the full amount owed, the debtor may be required to report the forgiven debt as regular income, with certain exceptions. The forgiven debts include money owed after foreclosure or property repossession or credit accounts are not paid. Exceptions noted below.

If a lender forgives or writes off $600 or more of a debt's principal (the amount not including interest or fees) the lender must send the debtor and IRS a Form 1099-C at the end of the year. When the debtor files tax returns for the tax year in which the debt was written off, the IRS requires that the amount is reported as income.

Warning: The debtor may not receive this form from the creditor even though the creditor submitted the form to the IRS. If the creditor does list the income on their tax return and the IRS has the information of the transaction on file, the debtor could get a tax bill or, worse, an audit notice.

There are several exceptions stated in the Internal Revenue Code. For example, you do not have to report the income on your tax return if the write off of the debt is intended as a gift, you discharge the debt in bankruptcy, or you were insolvent before the creditor agreed to settle or write off the debt. Always encourage the debtor to consult qualified tax and legal counsel to see if these circumstances apply.

It is important to realize the tax implication is only on the amount of the forgiven debt.

Example: The lender is owed $150,000 and agrees to accept a $100,000 short sale. The amount of forgiven debt is $50,000 and the most the lender could report on a 1099. Assuming the debtor was in a 15% tax bracket the tax consequences would be $7,500.

By comparison if the property was sold at public auction and brings $100,000 the lender could seek a deficiency judgment against the mortgagor to recover the $50,000 shortage, plus foreclosure expenses. The short sale is the much better alternative.